This is the third in a series of responses to Sean Tatol’s issue 37 essay “After the Post-Avant-Garde: How to return to art history.” Read the first response, by James Elkins, here, and read Tatol’s response to Elkins here. Read the second response, by Joe Bucciero, here. And stay tuned in the coming weeks for responses from other art critics and theorists.
●
“Only art can make us see the world with fresh eyes,” Sean Tatol claims at the end of his essay “After the Post-Avant Garde: How to return to art history.” Why do writers keep declaiming things like this? Editors at The Point: Why do you let this kind of thing through? Because my vision gets tweaked and improved by all sorts of things all of the time. When I wake up early and walk outside in pink light it happens. And when I fall in love it happens too. After a lecture or at the end of a classroom discussion—eyes freshened! I once saw an Alexander Wang billboard hanging over Canal Street that I still think about—an enormous pair of underwear stretched over the street! (Eyes glistening.) A political victory that I never thought possible made for truly optical astringence. If only art were capable of offering a fresh view of the world, the world—our world—would be an impossibly dark and impoverished place.
It’s true that things, including the art world, are changing, but that doesn’t mean we should return to old shibboleths and rote slogans. Tatol is tired of the avant-garde and its critical tradition; he wants to mark its end and rekindle art’s magic. But there’s no turning back. I get that the current artistic moment feels redundant and untenable. His description of the post-avant-garde as an ambivalent and “nuanced” cadre is an apt gloss of a current crop of downtown artists but it barely tweaks an old argument put forth by the German critic Peter Bürger in his 1974 book Theory of the Avant-Garde, translated into English in 1984. In that book Bürger claims that whereas the historical avant-gardes (your Futurists, Dadaists, Constructivist and Surrealists) upended everyday life by shocking it, the neo-avant-garde of the 1950s and Sixties returned their provocations to the institution of art. Bürger’s argument was a hair too neat but it established terms for debates that animated art practice in the West for decades to come.1 Tatol rehearses Bürger’s line with slightly different nomenclature. I assume he knows this even though he doesn’t mention Bürger by name.
As a way out of the avant-garde/post-avant-garde paradigm Tatol advocates for the return of what he calls art history, but which sounds more like an ersatz version of world culture: art today should draw from “an open field” and “an embarrassment of riches,” he writes, inspired as much by the temples of Angkor Wat as the institutional critique of Michael Asher. His prescription boils down to: Walk through the Met, take a bong rip and channel the centuries. All the world is at your disposal, artists, so why not make something great to sit along the masterpieces? And the internet makes it easy. The Frenchman André Malraux put forth the idea of a “museum without walls” in the 1940s: Photography had made all the world’s patrimony mobile and readily available, so let’s use it, he figured. Use the latest technology to make an art that can stand the test of time. Tatol adds: Now with WiFi. Artists, set your Pluralism to MaxOverdrive and aim for the stars. Sure, I’m thinking, blast off, but that’s not contemporary art.
Contemporary art is art that tries to meet its moment. It takes a breath, inhales toxins, fumes, powders, zeitgeists, algorithms, commodities, stardust, theories, politics, labor, whatever’s lying around of history, and ekes out some wild combination of these things in a surprising new form. And then the artist considers what they’ve made and maybe puts it forward as a candidate for art. In a recent essay, the artist Josh Kline implored young artists to leave New York and set up shop in Philadelphia. The idea is that life is cheaper there and one can focus on one’s work. You first, Josh! was my initial thought. But my second thought was: Yes, New York is terribly expensive and brutal but it’s also a dynamic place where lots of people circulate and live. A lot of power resides here, too. And toxicity. And art. Contemporary art’s project is to work within the constraints of its time and place, not dodge them. It’s the job of the arts—and I include the liberal arts here—to figure out ways of living in the world that feel just and right, not dip out on them. Conceptual art in the 1960s and Seventies, for example, was, amongst other things, a response to a society increasingly organized around information as well as an impending economic crisis. If conceptual artists had moved elsewhere, they’d still be painting masterpieces and we’d be the worse for it.
Contemporary art might sound like a commonplace thing today, but it denotes a very specific relationship to time; the term, in fact, only entered art discourse after World War II. The christening of the Institute of Contemporary Arts in London in 1946 makes for a good starting point—and that was a place saturated with a thousand ideas about how to navigate postwar culture. (See the interdisciplinary investigations of the Independent Group for a breathtaking array of possibilities.) A lot of the time I don’t think we sufficiently consider what contemporary art really means. Sure, all art was contemporary once, insofar as it was made in a specific moment in time, and art from earlier epochs that remains today has some relationship with our own time, too. “Contemporary art,” however, is art uniquely aimed at its own moment, an art that somehow possesses an increased awareness of its place in time—and aims to maneuver within it.
In his 1952 book Eclipse of God the Jewish theologian Martin Buber tells a story about an elderly acquaintance who suggests retiring the word god. He’s living in the wake of the Holocaust and the devastation of World War II. He’s dissatisfied with god—what holy force could have allowed this to happen?—but he also senses that the word had become a hodgepodge, that it meant all things to all people but too little to too many. It’s a mutt word, diluted yet terribly potent despite—or perhaps because of—its incoherence. What would happen if the word were dropped? Buber took a counter-position. He refused to let the word god go. He was wise enough not to fall for prelapsarian fantasies about a world without language. He realized that god was his inheritance and that he had to wrestle with it day in and day out.
I share Buber’s position, but sometimes I play a thought experiment where I vanquish contemporary art. In this imagined world there’s no art class. Or art school. Or art therapy. It’s the Metropolitan Museum of. The Whitney Museum of American. Artists are -ists. There are fairs but no art fairs. All the MFAs are canceled. I’m out of a job. I’m not sure what I’d do but that’s not the worst of it. The part that turns my stomach is the culture of making that replaces the world of art. Tinkering without words. Soapmaking without end. A culture of unchecked creativity. Of doing and doers. Just makers and bakers and ceramic shapers. It sounds a lot like the world we live in, in fact. (It’s Brooklyn. Forget Dimes Square—Brooklyn is still the problem. Queens is the future.)
So maybe what I’m saying is that we’ve already gotten rid of contemporary art. Art has been thoroughly humiliated by our world. Almost nobody wants it. All its terrible self-consciousness makes us embarrassed. All its questions about itself—Why this form, this color? Why is this big and this small? Why does it reference something I don’t understand? Why does it bring people together and sometimes drive them apart? The questions of value it begs and confuses—all this makes people uncomfortable. Museums especially want nothing to do with it. Art is not practical—and it takes time—and suddenly we live in a very practical, no-nonsense age. We want results and tingles and we want them sooner rather than later. Given these circumstances I want to propose an inversion of Buber’s friend’s thought experiment for our current moment: We’ll say art all the time. It’s not that we’ll call everything art (quite the opposite in fact), but we will talk endlessly about what contemporary art might be, where it belongs and what it might do. Tatol, in fact, takes part in this project with considerable bravura in his inimitable blog, Manhattan Art Review.
Which brings us to the question of language. One thing we need to do is to take a good measure of art’s potential. We can’t keep using overinflated rhetoric. We need to temper the heroism, which ranges from artists to the barricades to only art can freshen eyes. We need to rescale art, and the talk around art. Andrea Fraser, who Tatol discusses at length in his essay only to parody her as a model of complicity, makes this point in her 2012 essay, “There’s No Place Like Home,” included in that year’s Whitney Biennial catalog. “Much of what is written about art now seems to me to be almost delusional in the grandiosity of its claims for social impact and critique,” she writes. And at the very end of her essay, she returns to the question of language, asking us to pay extra care to “art discourse.” “While a transformation in art discourse would not, of course, resolve any of the enormous conflicts in the social world or even within ourselves, it might at least allow us to engage them more honestly and effectively,” she writes. I take this charge seriously. Fraser is talking about scale. The scale of our claims. The scale of our expectations. Yes, Courbet led the Paris Commune’s charge against the Vendôme column, but that’s not the entire, or only, story about modern art. Art pokes and prods at life in a million different ways. It gives a little space to the viewer to consider how to move forward. It might be a moment of respite or a call to action. So, no, I don’t want to be “liberated from the pretenses of contemporaneity,” as Tatol suggests. Which does not mean that it’s art’s duty to report the news, which it’s not particularly good at. But it can animate and dissect the news, as we saw in Hamza Walker’s epochal MONUMENTS exhibition this past year. There are a lot of ways to be contemporary. Il faut être de son temps—still!
Art’s reception, in fact, might be even more crucial than its production—and Tatol mostly treats the demise of the former as a foregone conclusion. But this is what we need to hold onto. I am an institutionalist. I don’t believe art can happen anywhere, and I don’t believe that art’s identity rests solely with the intentions of the artist. Art has to enter a system of meaning—a studio, a seminar room, an apartment gallery, a museum—where its merits can be appraised and discussed. That’s how art becomes civic and social. I also believe in a kind of semi-autonomy of the artwork—that art has a strange oblique relationship to life. It is neither wholly independent from the world nor is its meaning completely ratified by what’s going on outside. This is made clear by the advent of the readymade: put a urinal in a museum and it really does become something else. It also points back at the world and makes that strange, too. I think museums, including university art museums and artist-run spaces, are vital for maintaining this strangeness—I call it good alienation. Museums are weird and cold places and they should be different from movie theaters and shopping malls.
Perhaps the most inspiring exhibition I saw this year was a display of the art collection of the Martinican writer Édouard Glissant (1928-2011), the great thinker of errantry and the author of Poetics of Relation (1990), at the Center for Art, Research and Alliances (CARA) in Manhattan. Glissant made it his life’s work to imagine inverted versions of our present world—instead of globalization à la the corporations there would be globalité, an endless adventure comprised of new ways of coming together. While Glissant has been taken up by the world of contemporary art, to my knowledge he wrote little on art itself, and yet, judging from the size and power and heterogeneity of his collection, he cared about it deeply. The works in his care served as thought objects for him, aids to theory. He theorized alongside and with these works. And they made me think, too, about how we might navigate the world today. There was a fantastic wooden sculpture suspended in a corner by the Cuban artist Agustín Cárdenas that boldly took hold of its site; a delirious 1947 figurative canvas by the Romanian surrealist Victor Brauner; a 1982 abstract sculpture by the American artist Melvin Edwards dedicated to the Cuban-Chinese artist Wifredo Lam, who himself often collaborated with Glissant; and biting political maps by the Swedish polymath Öyvind Fahlström. Not an incoherent internet of things or images but a collection of material connections. A truly international cast of artists all concerned with mapping out new vectors in the world—with wit and whimsy, humor and satire (and desire, too). Art not simply as symptom but a space for agency. For Glissant, art was an invitation to voyage. He obviously needed it desperately. Artists can help construct this craft, but so can curators, collectors and critics. That’s the boat I want to get onto. The boat going elsewhere and across. What will we take with us and where will we go? For me and others, contemporary art still promises one route for a meaningful trip.
●
Sean Tatol and Alex Kitnick will be in conversation Friday, November 20th at Ulrik about the neo-avant-garde, the post-avant-garde and contemporary art today. Find more info here.
This is the third in a series of responses to Sean Tatol’s issue 37 essay “After the Post-Avant-Garde: How to return to art history.” Read the first response, by James Elkins, here, and read Tatol’s response to Elkins here. Read the second response, by Joe Bucciero, here. And stay tuned in the coming weeks for responses from other art critics and theorists.
●
“Only art can make us see the world with fresh eyes,” Sean Tatol claims at the end of his essay “After the Post-Avant Garde: How to return to art history.” Why do writers keep declaiming things like this? Editors at The Point: Why do you let this kind of thing through? Because my vision gets tweaked and improved by all sorts of things all of the time. When I wake up early and walk outside in pink light it happens. And when I fall in love it happens too. After a lecture or at the end of a classroom discussion—eyes freshened! I once saw an Alexander Wang billboard hanging over Canal Street that I still think about—an enormous pair of underwear stretched over the street! (Eyes glistening.) A political victory that I never thought possible made for truly optical astringence. If only art were capable of offering a fresh view of the world, the world—our world—would be an impossibly dark and impoverished place.
It’s true that things, including the art world, are changing, but that doesn’t mean we should return to old shibboleths and rote slogans. Tatol is tired of the avant-garde and its critical tradition; he wants to mark its end and rekindle art’s magic. But there’s no turning back. I get that the current artistic moment feels redundant and untenable. His description of the post-avant-garde as an ambivalent and “nuanced” cadre is an apt gloss of a current crop of downtown artists but it barely tweaks an old argument put forth by the German critic Peter Bürger in his 1974 book Theory of the Avant-Garde, translated into English in 1984. In that book Bürger claims that whereas the historical avant-gardes (your Futurists, Dadaists, Constructivist and Surrealists) upended everyday life by shocking it, the neo-avant-garde of the 1950s and Sixties returned their provocations to the institution of art. Bürger’s argument was a hair too neat but it established terms for debates that animated art practice in the West for decades to come.1In my own work I have argued that the neo-avant-garde kept its sights sets on the world but that it did its business in less openly antagonistic ways. Tatol rehearses Bürger’s line with slightly different nomenclature. I assume he knows this even though he doesn’t mention Bürger by name.
As a way out of the avant-garde/post-avant-garde paradigm Tatol advocates for the return of what he calls art history, but which sounds more like an ersatz version of world culture: art today should draw from “an open field” and “an embarrassment of riches,” he writes, inspired as much by the temples of Angkor Wat as the institutional critique of Michael Asher. His prescription boils down to: Walk through the Met, take a bong rip and channel the centuries. All the world is at your disposal, artists, so why not make something great to sit along the masterpieces? And the internet makes it easy. The Frenchman André Malraux put forth the idea of a “museum without walls” in the 1940s: Photography had made all the world’s patrimony mobile and readily available, so let’s use it, he figured. Use the latest technology to make an art that can stand the test of time. Tatol adds: Now with WiFi. Artists, set your Pluralism to MaxOverdrive and aim for the stars. Sure, I’m thinking, blast off, but that’s not contemporary art.
Contemporary art is art that tries to meet its moment. It takes a breath, inhales toxins, fumes, powders, zeitgeists, algorithms, commodities, stardust, theories, politics, labor, whatever’s lying around of history, and ekes out some wild combination of these things in a surprising new form. And then the artist considers what they’ve made and maybe puts it forward as a candidate for art. In a recent essay, the artist Josh Kline implored young artists to leave New York and set up shop in Philadelphia. The idea is that life is cheaper there and one can focus on one’s work. You first, Josh! was my initial thought. But my second thought was: Yes, New York is terribly expensive and brutal but it’s also a dynamic place where lots of people circulate and live. A lot of power resides here, too. And toxicity. And art. Contemporary art’s project is to work within the constraints of its time and place, not dodge them. It’s the job of the arts—and I include the liberal arts here—to figure out ways of living in the world that feel just and right, not dip out on them. Conceptual art in the 1960s and Seventies, for example, was, amongst other things, a response to a society increasingly organized around information as well as an impending economic crisis. If conceptual artists had moved elsewhere, they’d still be painting masterpieces and we’d be the worse for it.
Contemporary art might sound like a commonplace thing today, but it denotes a very specific relationship to time; the term, in fact, only entered art discourse after World War II. The christening of the Institute of Contemporary Arts in London in 1946 makes for a good starting point—and that was a place saturated with a thousand ideas about how to navigate postwar culture. (See the interdisciplinary investigations of the Independent Group for a breathtaking array of possibilities.) A lot of the time I don’t think we sufficiently consider what contemporary art really means. Sure, all art was contemporary once, insofar as it was made in a specific moment in time, and art from earlier epochs that remains today has some relationship with our own time, too. “Contemporary art,” however, is art uniquely aimed at its own moment, an art that somehow possesses an increased awareness of its place in time—and aims to maneuver within it.
In his 1952 book Eclipse of God the Jewish theologian Martin Buber tells a story about an elderly acquaintance who suggests retiring the word god. He’s living in the wake of the Holocaust and the devastation of World War II. He’s dissatisfied with god—what holy force could have allowed this to happen?—but he also senses that the word had become a hodgepodge, that it meant all things to all people but too little to too many. It’s a mutt word, diluted yet terribly potent despite—or perhaps because of—its incoherence. What would happen if the word were dropped? Buber took a counter-position. He refused to let the word god go. He was wise enough not to fall for prelapsarian fantasies about a world without language. He realized that god was his inheritance and that he had to wrestle with it day in and day out.
I share Buber’s position, but sometimes I play a thought experiment where I vanquish contemporary art. In this imagined world there’s no art class. Or art school. Or art therapy. It’s the Metropolitan Museum of. The Whitney Museum of American. Artists are -ists. There are fairs but no art fairs. All the MFAs are canceled. I’m out of a job. I’m not sure what I’d do but that’s not the worst of it. The part that turns my stomach is the culture of making that replaces the world of art. Tinkering without words. Soapmaking without end. A culture of unchecked creativity. Of doing and doers. Just makers and bakers and ceramic shapers. It sounds a lot like the world we live in, in fact. (It’s Brooklyn. Forget Dimes Square—Brooklyn is still the problem. Queens is the future.)
So maybe what I’m saying is that we’ve already gotten rid of contemporary art. Art has been thoroughly humiliated by our world. Almost nobody wants it. All its terrible self-consciousness makes us embarrassed. All its questions about itself—Why this form, this color? Why is this big and this small? Why does it reference something I don’t understand? Why does it bring people together and sometimes drive them apart? The questions of value it begs and confuses—all this makes people uncomfortable. Museums especially want nothing to do with it. Art is not practical—and it takes time—and suddenly we live in a very practical, no-nonsense age. We want results and tingles and we want them sooner rather than later. Given these circumstances I want to propose an inversion of Buber’s friend’s thought experiment for our current moment: We’ll say art all the time. It’s not that we’ll call everything art (quite the opposite in fact), but we will talk endlessly about what contemporary art might be, where it belongs and what it might do. Tatol, in fact, takes part in this project with considerable bravura in his inimitable blog, Manhattan Art Review.
Which brings us to the question of language. One thing we need to do is to take a good measure of art’s potential. We can’t keep using overinflated rhetoric. We need to temper the heroism, which ranges from artists to the barricades to only art can freshen eyes. We need to rescale art, and the talk around art. Andrea Fraser, who Tatol discusses at length in his essay only to parody her as a model of complicity, makes this point in her 2012 essay, “There’s No Place Like Home,” included in that year’s Whitney Biennial catalog. “Much of what is written about art now seems to me to be almost delusional in the grandiosity of its claims for social impact and critique,” she writes. And at the very end of her essay, she returns to the question of language, asking us to pay extra care to “art discourse.” “While a transformation in art discourse would not, of course, resolve any of the enormous conflicts in the social world or even within ourselves, it might at least allow us to engage them more honestly and effectively,” she writes. I take this charge seriously. Fraser is talking about scale. The scale of our claims. The scale of our expectations. Yes, Courbet led the Paris Commune’s charge against the Vendôme column, but that’s not the entire, or only, story about modern art. Art pokes and prods at life in a million different ways. It gives a little space to the viewer to consider how to move forward. It might be a moment of respite or a call to action. So, no, I don’t want to be “liberated from the pretenses of contemporaneity,” as Tatol suggests. Which does not mean that it’s art’s duty to report the news, which it’s not particularly good at. But it can animate and dissect the news, as we saw in Hamza Walker’s epochal MONUMENTS exhibition this past year. There are a lot of ways to be contemporary. Il faut être de son temps—still!
Art’s reception, in fact, might be even more crucial than its production—and Tatol mostly treats the demise of the former as a foregone conclusion. But this is what we need to hold onto. I am an institutionalist. I don’t believe art can happen anywhere, and I don’t believe that art’s identity rests solely with the intentions of the artist. Art has to enter a system of meaning—a studio, a seminar room, an apartment gallery, a museum—where its merits can be appraised and discussed. That’s how art becomes civic and social. I also believe in a kind of semi-autonomy of the artwork—that art has a strange oblique relationship to life. It is neither wholly independent from the world nor is its meaning completely ratified by what’s going on outside. This is made clear by the advent of the readymade: put a urinal in a museum and it really does become something else. It also points back at the world and makes that strange, too. I think museums, including university art museums and artist-run spaces, are vital for maintaining this strangeness—I call it good alienation. Museums are weird and cold places and they should be different from movie theaters and shopping malls.
Perhaps the most inspiring exhibition I saw this year was a display of the art collection of the Martinican writer Édouard Glissant (1928-2011), the great thinker of errantry and the author of Poetics of Relation (1990), at the Center for Art, Research and Alliances (CARA) in Manhattan. Glissant made it his life’s work to imagine inverted versions of our present world—instead of globalization à la the corporations there would be globalité, an endless adventure comprised of new ways of coming together. While Glissant has been taken up by the world of contemporary art, to my knowledge he wrote little on art itself, and yet, judging from the size and power and heterogeneity of his collection, he cared about it deeply. The works in his care served as thought objects for him, aids to theory. He theorized alongside and with these works. And they made me think, too, about how we might navigate the world today. There was a fantastic wooden sculpture suspended in a corner by the Cuban artist Agustín Cárdenas that boldly took hold of its site; a delirious 1947 figurative canvas by the Romanian surrealist Victor Brauner; a 1982 abstract sculpture by the American artist Melvin Edwards dedicated to the Cuban-Chinese artist Wifredo Lam, who himself often collaborated with Glissant; and biting political maps by the Swedish polymath Öyvind Fahlström. Not an incoherent internet of things or images but a collection of material connections. A truly international cast of artists all concerned with mapping out new vectors in the world—with wit and whimsy, humor and satire (and desire, too). Art not simply as symptom but a space for agency. For Glissant, art was an invitation to voyage. He obviously needed it desperately. Artists can help construct this craft, but so can curators, collectors and critics. That’s the boat I want to get onto. The boat going elsewhere and across. What will we take with us and where will we go? For me and others, contemporary art still promises one route for a meaningful trip.
●
Sean Tatol and Alex Kitnick will be in conversation Friday, November 20th at Ulrik about the neo-avant-garde, the post-avant-garde and contemporary art today. Find more info here.
If you liked this essay, you’ll love reading The Point in print.